Educators Unions vs. Students|5 Minute Video
There is an issue in American education. On the one hand, teachers are necessary to trainee achievement. On the other, instructors unions promote self-interests of their members which are antithetical to the interests of trainees. How do we repair this issue? In 5 minutes, Terry Moe, Professor of Political Science at Stanford University, defines this predicament and provides services.
PragerU is experiencing extreme censorship on Big Tech platforms. Go to https://www.prageru.com/ to view our videos devoid of censorship!
SUBSCRIBE https://www.prageru.com/join/
Take PragerU videos with you everywhere you go. Download our free mobile app!
Download for Apple iOS ➡ https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/prage …
Download for Android ➡ https://play.google.com/store/apps/de …
Join PragerU’s text list! https://optin.mobiniti.com/prageru
STORE! Love PragerU? Visit our store today! https://shop.prageru.com/
Script:
Quickly after taking office, President Barack Obama’s secretary of education, Arne Duncan, acknowledged that America’s public school system is broken. “It’s apparent the system’s damaged,” he stated. “Let’s confess’s broken, let’s confess’s dysfunctional, and let’s do something drastically various, and let’s do it now. Let’s fix the thing.”
Why are America’s public schools stopping working? Why, after more than a quarter century of perpetual reform, has the nation been not able to bring genuine change to public education?
While a complete answer, obviously, would be extremely made complex. But at the heart of it lies the power of the teachers unions– the National Education Association, the American Federation of Teachers, and their state and local affiliates.
I do not state this out of some sort of anti-union ideology. I say it as an objective description of the reality, backed by a huge amount of information. Union power has created insurmountable problems for reliable schools.
Why has this happened? Partly, it’s because the instructors unions are by far the most powerful groups in American education. More than that, they are unique interest groups, which suggests that they use their power to promote the unique interests– the task interests– of their members. They are not in business of representing the interests of children, and nobody ought to anticipate them to do that.
The purpose of a union is to represent the task interests of its members– and these interests are simply not the like the interests of kids. How, then, do they pursue these job interests? They do it in two ways.
The very first is through collective bargaining, which occurs in local school districts. Through collective bargaining, the unions are able to win numerous restrictive work guidelines, written into binding agreements that define how the schools must be organized.
Typically, for example, these agreements consist of wage guidelines requiring that instructors be paid entirely on the basis of seniority and credentials, with no regard for whether their trainees are actually learning anything.
Typically, these contracts likewise consist of seniority guidelines that allow senior instructors to take preferable jobs when they come open– even if these instructors are average in the class or a bad suitable for the school.
There are also seniority guidelines needing that, in layoff situations, exceptional young instructors need to be let go– automatically– and their senior associates must be continued no matter how unskilled they may be.
Labor agreements are simply filled with these sort of perverse rules.
Nobody who’s believing just of what is finest for kids would ever arrange the schools in this method. Yet this is how America’s schools are really organized.
The other method instructors unions form the general public schools is through the political process– where they just have far more influence than any other education groups, by lots of orders of magnitude. They have more than four million members, they’re leading factors to political campaigns, they have armies of activists in the electoral trenches, they have lobbying organizations in all fifty states, and far more.
They have actually utilized this political clout to block or substantially weaken significant reforms.
For the total script, go to https://www.prageru.com/videos/teachers-unions-vs-students
source
On the other, instructors unions promote self-interests of their members which are antithetical to the interests of trainees. Union power has actually produced overwhelming issues for effective schools.
Partially, it’s because the instructors unions are by far the most powerful groups in American education. More than that, they are unique interest groups, which suggests that they use their power to promote the special interests– the job interests– of their members. The purpose of a union is to represent the job interests of its members– and these interests are just not the very same as the interests of kids.
