Does Israel Occupy the West Bank?
How numerous times have you heard that Israel “occupies “the West Bank? Eugene Kontorovich, professor of law at George Mason University, dives into these concerns and uncovers some surprising answers.
PragerU is experiencing severe censorship on Big Tech platforms. Go to https://www.prageru.com/ to watch our videos devoid of censorship!
SUBSCRIBE https://www.prageru.com/join/
Take PragerU videos with you all over you go. Download our totally free mobile app!
Download for Apple iOS âž¡ https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/prageru/id1115115779
Download for Android âž¡ https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.cappital.prageru
To see the FACTS & SOURCES and Transcript, check out: https://www.prageru.com/video/does-israel-occupy-the-west-bank
Join PragerU’s text list! https://optin.mobiniti.com/prageru
Love PragerU? Visit our store today!
Script:
How many times have you heard that Israel “occupies” the West Bank?
Most likely more times than you can count.
However have you ever asked yourself whether it’s real? And even what it indicates?
Let’s do so now in the most unbiased method possible; that is, in the manner in which all territorial questions all over else on the planet are dealt with.
To do this, we need to look at the law.
First, we require a little history.
Up till 100 years ago, the locations now called Israel, the West Bank, Gaza, and all the countries around them– were part of the Ottoman Empire, which ruled over a large area and many individuals. Neither the Jews nor those Arabs we now call Palestinians had a state, though the Jews had a nationalist motion requiring one.
Whatever changed after World War I. The Ottomans fought on the losing side with Germany. By end of the war in 1918, their empire had broken down, leaving the French and british in control of much of its area.
In earlier times, the victors would likely have actually kept this land as nests on their own. However there was a new spirit of democracy in the air. The allies– including the British, French, and Americans– concurred that the former Ottoman lands should be permitted to become independent nation-states.
After the war, the countries of the world produced the League of Nations, a precursor to the United Nations. Meeting in San Remo, Italy in 1920, they set up what was known as “the Mandate system.” The nests of the beat powers– Germany and the Ottoman Empire– were transformed into distinct geopolitical entities, which became the nations now referred to as Iraq, Lebanon, Syria, and Jordan.
None of this is questionable.
There was one other Mandate released– the Mandate for Palestine. “Palestine” was merely a geographical label– the name the Romans offered the Jewish Kingdom of Judea after they conquered it. There was absolutely nothing exclusively Arab about it.
The Mandate provided that Palestine would end up being a “national home” for the Jewish people. There was a basic factor for this: the League acknowledged that Jews were the native individuals of the area.
All the obligatory territories in the Middle East transitioned to statehood in the 30s and 40s, with Israel the last to do so, stating self-reliance in May 1948.
Now we get to the legal stuff.
What were the borders of the State of Israel when it stated independence?
International law has a simple and universally applicable rule for determining borders. It’s called the Uti possidetis juris principle (legal representatives enjoy Latin phrases). The guideline supplies that when a new country is developed, its borders match the borders of the previous geopolitical entity because area..
For example, the borders of Ukraine, Latvia, and Azerbaijan are exactly what they were when they belonged to the Soviet Union..
Other considerations, such as demographics, are not considered– because without a simple, easily-applied guideline, a new country’s borders would never be settled– a recipe for long-term conflict..
Using this guideline to Israel indicates that it had sovereign claims to all of Jerusalem, Judea and Samaria, and Gaza because those were its borders according to the Mandate of Palestine.
To be sure, the United Nations proposed a resolution in 1947 with various borders and a much smaller area for a Jewish state. That resolution was a non-binding recommendation. Absolutely nothing more. It did not have the force of law.
We know what occurred next.
Upon stating self-reliance, Israel was right away invaded by 5 Arab armies, looking for to destroy it.
Israel endured, but Jordan handled to take parts of Jerusalem, as well as Judea and Samaria, which it called “the West Bank.” All the Jews living in these locations were expelled– or, to use a contemporary term, ethnically cleansed.
Here we need to present another key principle of worldwide law: a war of hostility can not be utilized to change a nation’s borders.
For the total records check out: https://www.prageru.com/video/does-israel-occupy-the-west-bank.
source
How many times have you heard that Israel “occupies “the West Bank? Eugene Kontorovich, professor of law at George Mason University, dives into these concerns and reveals some surprising answers.
The colonies of the defeated powers– Germany and the Ottoman Empire– were transformed into unique geopolitical entities, which ended up being the countries now known as Iraq, Lebanon, Syria, and Jordan.
There was one other Mandate released– the Mandate for Palestine. To be sure, the United Nations proposed a resolution in 1947 with various borders and a much smaller area for a Jewish state.
