What’s Wrong With The 1619 Project?
In August of 2019, the New York Times launched The 1619 Project. Its goal is to redefine the American experiment as rooted not in liberty however in slavery. In this video, Wilfred Reilly, Associate Professor of Political Science at Kentucky State University, responds to The 1619 Project’s major claims.
FOLLOW us!
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/prageru.
Twitter: https://twitter.com/prageru.
Instagram: https://instagram.com/prageru/.
SUBSCRIBE so you never ever miss out on a brand-new video! https://www.prageru.com/join/.
To see the script, sources, test, visit https://www.prageru.com/video/whats-wrong-with-the-1619-project.
Join PragerU’s text list to have these videos, completely complimentary merchandise totally free gifts and breaking declarations sent out directly to your phone! https://optin.mobiniti.com/prageru.
Do you shop on Amazon? Click https://smile.amazon.com and a portion of every Amazon purchase will be contributed to PragerU. Really very same fantastic items. Extremely exact same low cost. Shopping made significant.
SHOP!
Love PragerU? Now you can use PragerU product!
Script:.
Have you become conscious of The 1619 Project? It was released by the New York Times in August of 2019. It won the Pulitzer Prize for Commentary in 2020.
Its thesis: The United States was developed in 1619, when the extremely first servant was given North America.
Wait– that brings up some concerns …
What happened to 1776? George Washington, Thomas Jefferson, and James Madison?
According to The 1619 Project, the Founding Fathers pushed for all that “Life, Liberty and the Pursuit of Happiness” things to safeguard their servant holdings. Self-reliance from England? That was just a smoke screen.
To them, whatever that’s incorrect with America is connected to her “original sin” of slavery: from partition to traffic jam (yes– traffic jam!). For The 1619 Project authors, bigotry is not a part of the American experience; it is the American experience.
Is this real? Let’s take a look at three of the job’s major claims:.
1. Preserving slavery was the genuine cause of the American Revolution.
If you asked the Founders why they no longer wanted to be a British nest, they would have provided you a long list of reasons: Taxation without representation, disagreements over debts from the Indian and french War, and the Stamp Act would be merely a few.
More than likely essential was the burning desire to be totally complimentary– to chart their own fate as a sovereign nation. Safeguarding slavery? Slavery was not under danger from the British. Britain didn’t totally free the servants in its abroad colonies up till 1833– 57 years later on, after the Declaration of Independence.
Yes, the subject of slavery was increasingly challenged at the Constitutional Convention, however that wanted the war was won.
2. Slavery made America rich.
Slavery made some Americans abundant– true enough. The organization of slavery didn’t make America rich.
As economist Thomas Sowell mentions, in 1860, just one year before the Civil War began, the South had just one-sixth as lots of factories as the North. Nearly 90% of the nation’s experienced, well-paid employees and specialists were based in the North.
And the cost of removing slavery was huge– not simply in regards to dollars (Lincoln acquired billions to spend for it), however also in regards to human life: 360,000 Union soldiers passed away in order to totally free 4 million slaves. That exercises to about one soldier in blue for each ten servants freed. It’s hard to take a look at that butcher’s costs and conclude that the country made a profit from slavery.
And great deals of things have really happened given that 1865. In the almost 200 years due to the fact that the Civil War, the population of the country has in fact grown almost 900% and our nationwide GDP has increased 12,000%. Slavery did not make America plentiful.
3. Bigotry is an unchangeable part of America.
This argument is more philosophical than academic, however it supports the entire 1619 Project. Since it recommends that the United States is a naturally racist nation that can’t conquer its flaws, it’s likewise pernicious. Yet that’s exactly what it’s done.
Today, America is the most effective multi-racial country in history, the only white bulk country to choose a black President– two times. Clearly, advancement has actually not constantly been smooth. There have actually been dreadful problems. To compare American mindsets about race today to America a hundred years ago, not to mention to 1619, is unreasonable.
For the overall script go to https://www.prageru.com/video/whats-wrong-with-the-1619-project.
source
Its objective is to redefine the American experiment as rooted not in liberty however in slavery. Slavery made some Americans plentiful– real enough. The organization of slavery didn’t make America plentiful. And the expense of abolishing slavery was massive– not merely in terms of dollars (Lincoln obtained billions to spend for it), however also in regards to human life: 360,000 Union soldiers passed away in order to complimentary 4 million servants. Slavery did not make America abundant.
The company of slavery didn’t make America rich. It’s difficult to look at that butcher’s costs and conclude that the country made a revenue from slavery.
Slavery did not make America plentiful.
The institution of slavery didn’t make America plentiful. Slavery did not make America rich.
